51ÁÔÆæ

Teaching Design and Mediation 

A diversity-sensitive teaching design and mediation of teaching content helps to create an inclusive, respectful and equitable learning environment. It promotes the unfolding of the individual potential of all learners and prepares them to actively and positively contribute to a diverse society. It is essential how knowledge is delivered, because not only the selection of content, but also appropriate, sensitive (visual) language, the design of the teaching materials, opportunities for participation, the use of a variety of methods and a good feedback and communication culture all have an impact on students' learning success.

2021_04_28_Bild_Leitfaden geschlechterinklusive und diversitätssensible Sprache

Not only is language a means of communication, an expression of consciousness and a reflection of reality, but it also constitutes reality. This means that it shapes our perception, our consciousness and therefore our ideas of reality.

A sensitive and inclusive use of language actively contributes to equal rights for all genders and to an appreciative way of addressing people. It is recommended to use forms of language that take this into account and appropriately represent women, transgender and intersex people as well as people who identify as non-binary. The gender star or gender gap is well suited for this; more recently the colon has also been established. This also includes the use of self-chosen names and personal pronouns. It is always important to consider the personal wishes of the people being addressed and to give them the opportunity to express these wishes without asking them in a discriminatory way or force an outing. In the context of teaching, this can be achieved, for example, by including a corresponding passage in the email signature or through introductions in which the pronouns can (but do not have to) be mentioned. Mentioning your own pronouns when introducing yourself can also signal an openness to the topic and emphasize that pronouns are not recognizable by a person's appearance.

Even if the debate about diversity-sensitive language is characterized by discussions about 'gendering', other identity-forming characteristics also play a role. In particular, the use of derogatory terms or terms with negative connotations relating to gender or gender identity, sexual orientation or identity, religious belief and world view, racist attributions (based on phenotypical characteristics, presumed origin, religion, name, etc.), personal and family migration experience and international educational biographies, social background and family educational background, social and financial status, physical and mental health issues and chronic illnesses, age, family status and care responsibilities in the family and caregiving, etc. can activate a person's experiences of discrimination and perpetuate stereotypes. As a general rule, self-designations should be preferred to external designations and the respective context of terms should be classified and taken into account.

After all, recommendations for gender-equitable or diversity-sensitive language are not a rigid set of rules, but are intended to show ways to improve one's own work through critical reflection and thus achieve greater sensitivity to diversity. Ultimately, it is a question of attitude: "I care about people experiencing discrimination!" from which, in turn, context-specific measures can be drawn.

handlungsempfehlungen

Just like language, images are not just representations of the world around us, but also have a significant influence on how we perceive our world. This gives us two principles for the visual design of teaching materials: 1) representation, i.e. to find and use forms that adequately represent all people and through which everyone can feel addressed and 2) anti-discrimination, i.e. to use creative means in such a way that they do not discriminate against anyone or that no one feels discriminated against.

Diversity-sensitive visual language therefore involves the conscious use of images, illustrations and visual elements that promote diversity and inclusion in visual communication and the avoidance of discriminatory representations. It raises awareness of diversity and sensitivity to different experiences and perspectives and plays a crucial role in creating representation of often less visible groups. People of different origins, genders, ages, sexual orientations, body types, abilities and social backgrounds should be shown in images to reflect the diversity of the real world. It is important to avoid clichés and stereotypes, to be respectful of different cultures and traditions and not to promote cultural appropriation or stereotypes.

Gender justice, i.e. the balanced representation of all genders and the avoidance of gender stereotypes, is just as much a part of this as age justice, i.e. as the representation of the diversity of age, from children to senior citizens, as well as the representation of different body shapes. Diversity-sensitive imagery should also take into account people with disabilities by using accessible images (for more information, see Organization, Technology, Accessibility (Link)) and ensuring that all people and body types are represented equally. The visual language should include people of different sexual orientations and gender identities. Diversity-sensitive visual representations are also critical of racism by addressing, questioning or combating racism. The choice of colors, especially skin colors, should be made carefully so as not to exclude anyone or portray them in a discriminatory way.

Images should also be authentic and always respectful. They should respect the consent of the people depicted, especially in contexts where privacy or personal stories play a role.

The use of a variety of teaching methods in university teaching can help to:

  • Create an interactive learning environment, 
  • increase student participation and reduce barriers, and
  • thus, also improve learning outcomes.

The choice of methods should depend on the teaching objectives, the subject discipline and the needs of the students. A combination of different methods can create an enriching learning experience, strengthen students' skills in different areas and cater for students' different learning styles and preferences.

Care should also be taken to allow sufficient time for student discussion and interaction and not to overload the seminar with learning material so that there is no time left for participation. The interests and experiences of the participants should also be incorporated into the seminar.

In addition, clear expectations regarding student participation should be set at the beginning of the seminar. This can take the form of rules, guidelines or goals that define the nature of participation. This encourages students to take responsibility for their own learning journey.

It is also important to obtain regular feedback (see feedback culture) on the design of the seminar and the opportunity for participation. This allows improvements to be made and the students' needs to be taken into account.

Here are some examples of diverse and interactive teaching methods: 

  • Discussions allow students to actively participate in the learning process, exchange ideas and think critically. It is your job as a teacher to chair the discussion and ensure that all participants have the opportunity to express themselves. You can ask questions, encourage conversations and should make sure that no one dominates the discussion or behaves in a discriminatory manner. In addition, students can be given the task of leading the discussion in order to involve them even more actively.
  • Group work and team projects: Some students feel more comfortable in smaller groups and are then more likely to participate. Therefore, organize regular small group projects to deepen discussions and promote exchange. Working in groups or teams also promotes students' social and cooperative skills. They can work together on projects to gain practical experience.
  • Activation methods: These include activities such as brainstorming, role-playing, simulations and other experiential learning methods. The use of shorter written assignments during the seminar can support the participation of students who are more reluctant to speak. These can, for example, also be written anonymously and brought into the classroom, which can reduce further barriers to participation.
  • Flip-the-classroom model: This reverses the traditional teaching approach by making learning content available online before the lecture and using the lecture time for active discussions and exercises.
  • Online-Tools: The integration of e-learning platforms, virtual courses and web-based resources extends the opportunities for learning and allows flexible time management. The use of online discussions and forums allows students to exchange thoughts and opinions, even outside the classroom. In digital courses, you can also use various online tools to ease participation, such as surveys, chat rooms or discussion forums.
  • Reflection and feedback: Continuous reflection on teaching design and feedback from students can help to adapt and improve teaching methods and materials on an ongoing basis. Involving students in the assessment process, for example through peer feedback and assessment, also promotes self-reflection and the development of evaluation skills.
  • Guest lectures and expert presentations: Involving guest lecturers and experts from the industry to bring current insights and experiences into the classroom provides students with hands-on learning.
  • Practice: Case studies, field studies or internships provide practical examples and realistic scenarios that help students apply their theoretical knowledge to real-life situations.

Establishing a feedback culture in courses that goes beyond the usual final evaluation promotes student learning and interaction. In everyday teaching, which is often stressful, it is important to create sufficient time and space for feedback.
  • Feedback is explicitly welcome in the course and is seen as a valuable contribution to improving the course. This should be mentioned right at the beginning.
  • Regular feedback sessions, in which students can express their thoughts, questions and suggestions on various aspects of the seminar such as teaching methods, materials or topics, should also provide sufficient time for follow-up discussions and reflections on the aspects raised. Different feedback formats should be used, such as verbal feedback in the group, written feedback, but also anonymous and/or digital feedback via online tools.
  • It is also important that points of criticism are addressed and, if necessary, adjustments are implemented. Not only does this contribute to the continuous improvement of your own teaching methods and content, but also shows your appreciation for student feedback.

Dominant speaking behavior occurs when a person speaks excessively in a conversational situation, dominates the speaking time and possibly excludes other participants.

Forms of dominant speaking behavior can be, for example: 

  • Antagonistic rhetoric, which is a conversational style where the main goal is to create contradiction, conflict or opposition. In opposition to constructive communication, which aims at understanding, consensus and cooperation, antagonistic rhetoric emphasizes differences and points of conflict;
  • Interruptions of other people;
  • Insults or discrimination;
  • Belittling other opinions;
  • Long monologues and frequent speaking up;
  • "Entitlement", i.e. the assumption that one's own opinion or needs should automatically take priority due to certain identity markers, without regard for the perspectives or concerns of others;
  • "Mansplaining", i.e. a certain dynamic between the genders where a man explains something to a woman or TIN* person in a condescending or lecturing way, often in a situation where the woman or TIN* person is already well informed about the topic;
  • Inappropriate reactions to statements made by others, such as eye rolling or similar.

It is your job as a teacher to create a balanced and respectful discussion environment in which all students are given the opportunity to contribute.

You can pay attention to the following points to counteract dominant speaking behavior:

  • Create awareness by establishing communication rules and emphasizing the importance of active participation;  
  • Active moderation that gives everyone the opportunity to express their opinion;
  • Use structured discussion formats, such as partner or small group work; 
  • Use a variety of interaction methods (see Participation and Variety of Methods);
  • Encourage active listening, for example by summarizing the statements of other students;
  • React to degrading statements and directly address dominant speaking behavior;
  • Regularly create space for reflection and feedback on the communication and discussion culture (see Feedback Culture);
  • Address as many students as possible and ask open questions;
  • Use gender-equitable and diversity-sensitive language;
  • Avoid defamatory terms or respond to them when others use them;
  • Who takes part in my courses? With what aim do the students come to the course?
  • What prior knowledge or special needs do the students have?
  • Do I know how to use gender-equitable and diversity-sensitive language and can I use it in a context-specific way?
  • When preparing my teaching materials, do I pay attention to diversity-sensitive visual language that promotes the representation of marginalized groups and can break down stereotypes?
  • Do I offer diverse, flexible and interactive learning opportunities (screencasts, audio files, texts, live connections, recordings in synchronous formats)?
  • Does my seminar include a variety of interactive (moderated) communication options, e.g. synchronous and asynchronous, which create opportunities for (more) introverted students to participate?
  • Do I offer sufficient time for feedback?
  • Do I try to encourage all students to take part in discussions and do I offer different opportunities for participation?
  • Do I ensure a pleasant communication culture and appropriate speaking behavior in my courses? Do I pay attention to dominant speaking behavior and counteract it?
  • Do I make my teaching materials as accessible as possible? As a lecturer, you support students affected by disabilities, but also users of mobile devices, for example. This includes:
    • digital structure (use of format templates for headings etc.)
    • Sufficient font size, contrasts, avoidance of background images, sans serif fonts where possible
    • Image descriptions as alternative texts, texts for audios and videos
  • Do I provide my learning materials with as much lead time as possible (for students with additional time requirements, irregular working hours)? Do I offer alternative formats or non-digital formats such as texts/homework?